Finite Difference Method (FDM) and Finite Volume Method (FVM) are compared in solving a two dimensional steady laminar flow and heat transfer in a parallel channel with constant wall temperature. FORTRAN programs are written using Patankar’s SIMPLER algorithm with staggered-grid arrangement. The velocity, pressure, temperature, and Nusselt Number (Nu) are solved and analyzed in the comparison.
The programs are tested with both the fully developed and developing flow. The numerical results of velocity, pressure gradient, entrance length, or Nu are compared with those analytical or experimental data in the literature to verify the accuracy of the programs. The optimization of the number of grids is also studied in the comparison
The FDM and FVM programs are used to study their difference in the numerical model, principles discrete scheme, nature of conservation, accuracy, and computation tine for the fluid flow and heat transfer in a parallel channel. Accurate numerical results can be achieved with optimization of grid size. It is verified FVM has better conservation results in mass, momentum & heat transfer due to its nature in numerical schemes used. The FDM generally needs more grids and computing time in order to get better results. When compared with those with analytical solutions. It is concluded that FVM is better than FDM in most flow conditions in the investigations studied.
Further studies for different thermal boundary conditions, such as constant wall heat flux, and for different geometries, such as circular tube, are suggested.
中文摘要
英文摘要
目錄
表目錄
圖目錄
符號說明
第一章 緒論
1-1 前言
1-2 研究動機
1-3 文獻回顧
第二章 理論分析與數值方法
2-1 基本假設
2-2 統御方程式
2-3 格點配置
2-3-1 交錯式格點
2-3-2 交錯式格點於邊界上之配置
2-4 有限差分法
2-4-1 有限差分法之動量離散方程式
2-4-2 有限差分法之壓力離散方程式
2-4-3 有限差分法之壓力修正離散方程式
2-4-4 有限差分法之能量離散方程式
2-5 有限體積法
2-5-1 有限體積法之動量離散方程式
2-5-2 有限體積法之壓力離散方程式
2-5-3 有限體積法之壓力修正離散方程式
2-5-4 有限體積法之能量離散方程式
2-6 SIMPLER數值方法
2-6-1 SIMPLER法簡介
2-6-2 SIMPLER求解步驟
2-7 加速收斂的方法
2-8 邊界條件
2-9 代數方程式
2-10 誤差標準設定
第三章 結果與討論
3-1 Bench mark測試
3-1-1 完全發展流速度場
3-1-2 完全發展流速度場
3-2 入口均勻流
3-2-1 均勻流速度場
3-2-2 均勻流速度場 & 固定壁溫
3-3 等格距最佳化測試
3-3-1 流場等格距最佳化測試
3-3-2 熱場等格距最佳化測試
3-4 不同普朗特數
3-5 FDM與FVM比較
3-5-1 流量比較
3-5-2 流場比較
3-5-3 效率比較
3-6 入口障礙物
3-6-1入口障礙物高度與迴流區長度之關係
3-6-2入口障礙物高度迴流區熱場之變化
3-6-3入口障礙物流場等格距最佳化測試
第四章 結論與展望
4-1 結論
4-2 展望
參考文獻
附圖
附錄 A FDM二維動量離散方程式推導
附錄 B FDM二維壓力修正值離散方程式推導
附錄 C FDM二維壓力離散方程式推導
附錄 D FDM二維能量離散方程式推導
附錄 E FVM二維動量離散方程式推導
附錄 F FVM二維壓力修正值離散方程式推導
附錄 G FVM二維能量離散方程式推導
附錄 H TDMA(TriDiagonal-Matrix Algorithm)代數方程式推導
附錄 I 圓管固定壁溫的局部紐賽數數值解推導
附錄 J 固定壁溫的局部紐賽數數值解推導
附錄 K 二維平板熱場的局部紐賽數經驗公式
誌謝
[1] Patankar S.V., 1981, “Numerical Heat Transfer and Fluid Flow”, McGraw-Hill, New York.
[2] Joel H. Ferziger Milovan Peric, 1997, “Computational Methods for Fluid Dynamics”, Springer
[3] Fletcher C.A.J. 1987, “Computational Techniques for Fluid Dynamics 2 – Specific Techniques for Different Flow Categories”, Springer-Verlag
[4] Klaus A. Hoffmann and Steve T. Chiang, 1995, “Computational Fluid Dynamics for Engineers – Volume I”, Engineering Education System.
[5] Pozrikidis C.,1997, “Introduction to Theoretical and Computational Fluid Dynamics”, New York Oxford
[6] Shah, R.K., and A. L. London 1978, “Laminar Flow Forced Convection in Ducts”, Academic, New York
[7] Munson B.R. and Young D.F., “Fundamentals of Fluid Mechanics”, Wiley
[8] R.K.Shah and A.L.London, 1978 ,”Laminar Flow Forced Convection in Ducts”, Supplement 1 to Advances in Heat Transfer , Acadamic Press , New York
[9] R.K.Shah and M.S.Bhatti, 1978 ,”Laminar convective heat transfer in ducts”, Chapter 3 in S.Kakac,R.K.Shah , and W.Aung,eds.,Handbook of Single-Phase Convective Heat Transfer , Wiley,New York
[10] Patrick H. Oosthuizen and David Naylor,1999 ,”Introduction to Convective Heat Transfer Analysis”,McGRAW-HILL,New York
[11] S. Kakac, R.K. Shah and A.E. Bergles,1983 ,” Low Reynolds number flow heat exchangers” Washington : Hemisphere Pub. Corp.,
[12] W.M. KayS and M.E. Crawford,1993 ,” Convective Heat and Mass Transfer” , McGRAW-HILL,New York
[13] Louis C. Burmeister,1993 ,” Convective Heat Transfer” , Wiley,New York
[14] John D. Anderson , Jr. , 1995 ”COMPUTATIONAL FLUID DYAMICS ” , McGRAW-HILL,New York
[15] H K Versteeg and W Malalasekera ,2007, “An Interoduction to computational Fluid Dynamics” , PEARSON Prentice Hall
[16] Patankar S.V., 1981, “Numerical Heat Transfer and Fluid Flow”, McGraw-Hill, New York. , pp.131-134
[17] Cuvelier , C. , Segal , A. , and vanSteenhoven , A.A.(1986). “Finite Element Method and Navier-Stokes Equations .” D. Reidel,Dordrecht , Holland
[18] Comini G , Del Giudices S A. A k-εmodel of turbulent flow. Numer Heat Transfer , 1985. 8:133-147
[19] Chen C J , Bernatz R , Carlson K D , Lin W L. Finite analytic method in flows and heat transfer. New York : Taylor & Francis , 2000. 216-230
[20] Kays, W.M.,and M.E. Crawfore, Convective Heat and Mass Transfer, McGraw-Hill, New York,1980
[21] Langhaar, H.L.,J.Appl.Mech.,64,A-55,1942
[22] 陶文銓 , 2004 ,”數值熱傳學”,西安交通大學出版社
[23] 盧建男, 2002, “不同障礙物分佈對三維矩形管層流場及熱場影響之數值分析”, 國立臺灣海洋大學
[24] 謝耀昌, 2005,“非等格距平行板層流場之數值分析”,國立臺灣海洋大學
[25] 林旻毅, 2005,“具障礙物平行板層流場及熱場非等格點之數值分析”, 國立臺灣海洋大學
[26] 林佑威, 2007, ”矩形管層流場及熱場之非等格距數值分析” ,國立臺灣海洋大學
[27] 陳詠傑, 2007, ”非等距格點平行板層流場及熱場之數值分析” ,國 立臺灣海洋大學
[28] 洪涇 ,1993, “ 微擾差分法解晰不可壓縮流場 ” ,國立臺灣海洋大學
[29] 徐大為 , 2007, “層流混合對流熱傳在通道內之數值分析” , 國立臺灣海洋大學